More women file civil suits against the Alexander brothers over sexual assault allegations

Eleven more women have filed civile lawsuits against one or more of the Alexander brothers, adding to the mountain of legal woes facing Tal, Oren and Alon Alexander over alleged sexual misconduct.

Along with state and federal criminal sex trafficking charges, the new complaints bring the number of known civil suits against the brothers to 17. Plaintiffs in 10 of the new suits are listed as Jane Does, with a woman named Leah Peters accounting for the other one.

Tal and Oren Alexander — once superstar agents in the luxury real estate world — are defendants in six of the suits. Oren’s twin brother Alon, who worked for their father’s private security film, is listed as a defendant in one of the new suits.

The 11 suits were filed in bulk, with the plaintiffs being co-represented by Antigone Curis of Curis Law and Andrew Van Arsdale of AVA Law Group.

“We commend these survivors for coming forward and standing up against their abusers and look forward to pursuing justice on their behalf,” Curis said in a statement provided to HousingWire.

The three brothers have consistently denied allegations of misconduct. They were arrested in December and are currently being held in the Brooklyn Metropolitan Detention Center after being denied bail on federal criminal charges. The FBI said it has spoken to more than 60 women who accuse the brothers of assault. Their federal trial is scheduled for Jan. 5, 2026.

The accusations in the new suits are remarkably similar to those in previously filed cases. The alleged victims say they were lured to an apartment under false pretenses and assaulted after they got there. Many of them believe they were drugged.

The complaints were filed under New York City’s Gender-Motivated Violence Act, which provides a window for sexual assault cases that previously would have been subject to statute of limitations. The window expires in March. E. Jean Carroll’s suit against President Donald Trump was filed under the same law.

One of the original civil cases, filed by Angelica Parker, was dismissed on a technicality. The judge ruled that New York State’s Adult Survivors Act supersedes the city’s law, and the window for the state law previously expired. Parker has the option to appeal.

In a court filing last week, representatives for the Alexanders accused Morgan & Morgan of pressuring Florida state prosecutors into filing criminal charges. The law firm is representing a Jane Doe mentioned in the state’s complaint.

The brothers’ attorneys said the state substantially relied on evidence provided by Morgan & Morgan and thus should be required to disclose that evidence. If proven true, it’s unclear how this would materially impact the case.

White-label brokerage Side is suing Tal, Oren and their defunct brokerage, Official Partners, for defaulting on a loan extended to the brothers in 2022. Recent developments in that case could be indicative of how dire their situation is. 

Lawyers with Allen Matkins are no longer representing them in the Side case, saying that the brothers have failed to pay them for their services. They also said that the Alexanders being incarcerated has made it “unreasonably difficult” to represent them. They claim they’ve made more than a dozen attempts to contact the brothers about the Side case and received “only cursory return of communications.”

The brothers asked the court to compel arbitration in the case but were denied. A judge granted Side’s request for a preliminary injunction to freeze the collateral on the loan, the tampering of which was listed as an event of default in Side’s complaint. An amended complaint accused the brothers of subsequently missing a payment on the loan.